Determinants of Customer Loyalty in Mobile Telecommunication Industry in Bangladesh

Table of contents

1. Introduction

angladesh is the third biggest telecom market in Asia after China and India. Mobile phone has become an indispensable part of Bangladesh's everyday-life that made the communication easier for both urban and rural people in Bangladesh. Every year the number of mobile subscribers has been increased dramatically. The subscriber base was 97.180 million by December 2012. Within four years, the subscriber base has reached more than 119 million by September, 2016 and is continuing to grow at constant rate (BTRC, 2017). Presently, there are five mobile phone operators operating in Bangladesh namely Grameenphone (GP), Banglalink, Robi (Aktel), Teletalk (state-owned company), and Airtel (Warid). Grameenphone is the market leader with 55 million subscribers followed by Banglalink with 29 million subscribers and Robi with 24 million subscribers. Telecommunication service providers offer a wide range of value added services, including SMS (Short Message Service), voice SMS, B MMS (Multimedia Message Service), voice services, information service, ringtone, games, electronic transaction, roaming, internet service, video call and customer care service (BTRC, 2017).

There is a fierce competition existing among telecom operators in Bangladesh. In this competitive market, customers are not loyal to one particular telecommunication company. The major telecommunication companies are continuously forced to consider how to create a loyal customer base that will not be eroded even in the face of severe competition. Therefore, it has become a paramount concern for the companies to stay alive and win the market share by making more customers loyal to their firms because acquiring a new customer can cost 6 to 7 times more than keeping or retaining existing customer (Kotler, 2012).

Since competition increases, customers bargaining power gets stronger, building trust and satisfaction becomes more important. Hence, companies should put more focus on factors affecting loyalty among consumers.

2. a) Problem Statement

There is a fierce competition existing in the mobile telecommunication sector in Bangladesh. So, subscribers now have various alternatives to choose mobile telephone company according to their convenience. Therefore, to maintain the leading position in this competitive market telecom operators have to identify the factors that create customer loyalty. Very few studies are conducted on the determinants of customer loyalty in telecom industry in the context of Bangladesh. Therefore, this study attempts to find out the determinants of customer loyalty in the telecom industry in Bangladesh.

3. b) Research Objectives

The broad objective of this study is to explore the critical determinants of customer loyalty in Bangladesh. To be specific, the study has the following objectives:

? To examine whether service quality has significant relationship on customer loyalty. ? To examine whether customer satisfaction has significant relationship on customer loyalty. ? To examine whether trust has significant relationship on customer loyalty. ? To examine whether switching cost has significant relationship on customer loyalty.

? To examine whether corporate image has significant relationship on customer loyalty. ? To identify the most dominant determinant that creates customer loyalty in telecom industry. ? To recommend some actions plan for telecom operators based on this research findings.

4. II.

Literature Review a) Customer Loyalty Loyalty as a concept has its root from the consumer behavior theory and is something that consumers may exhibit to brands, services or activities. Customer loyalty is the most important goal of implementing relationship marketing activities. Customer loyalty represents the repeat purchase behavior, and referring the company to other customers ).Oliver (1997) defined customer loyalty as "a deeply held commitment to rebury or repatronize a preferred product/service consistently in the future, thereby causing repetitive same brand or same brand set purchasing, despite situational influences and marketing efforts having the potential to cause switching behavior". Customer loyalty is viewed as the strength of the relationship between an individual's relative attitude and repeat patronage. To deal with highly competitive market, business is trying not only to attract and satisfy customer but also to create a long term relationship with these customers (Gremler and Brown, 1996). Zeneldin (2006) suggested that a company can create loyalty by giving reward for their loyalty. Training employees on relationship marketing skills are the way to make customer loyal to a particular company.

5. b) Service Quality

Service is any activity or benefit that one party can offer to another that is essentially intangible and does not result in the ownership of anything (Kotler, 2012). Service quality is a global judgment or attitude relating to a particular service (Fogli, 2006).According to Berry et al. (1988), service quality has become a significant differentiator and the most powerful competitive weapon which all the service organizations want to possess. Service quality is the result of an evaluation process where customers compare their expectations about a service with their perception of the service to be received (Gro¨nroos, 1984;Parasuraman et al., 1985Parasuraman et al., , 1988Parasuraman et al., , 1994). The service providers can create competitive advantage by providing high level of service quality (Yoo and Park, 2007).Service quality is determined by SERVQUAL model which includes the components of reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy, and tangibles (Parasuramanet al., 1985). Service quality dimensions vary from industry to industry. Customer loyalty results when the quality of network of the service provider is satisfactory and there are small rates of call failure (Jahanzeb et al., 2011).

According to Rahman and Ismail (2010), network quality is one of the significant factors in terms of evaluating service quality in determining the customer loyalty. Services Quality is a major determinant in customer retention and building value relationship (Venetis and Ghauri, 2004).Theoretically, there is positive relationships between service quality, and customer loyalty which are documented in the extant literature (Buzzell and Gale, 1987;Brown et al.,1992;Zeithaml et al.,1996).The above literature can come up with the following hypothesis: H1: There is a significant relationship between service quality and customer loyalty.

6. c) Customer Satisfaction

Customer satisfaction has been given much attention among theoretical literatures and practical researches. Fornell (1992) defined satisfaction as an overall evaluation dependent on the total purchase and consumption experience of the target product or service performance compared with repurchase expectations over time. There is a strong positive correlation between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty (Donioet al., 2006; Story and Hess, 2006;Cheng et al., 2008;Anderson & Sullivan, 1993;Bolton & Drew, 1991;Fornell, 1992). Numerous studies in the service sector have also empirically validated the link between satisfaction and behavioral intentions such as customer retention and word of mouth (Anderson & Sullivan, 1993;Bansal& Taylor, 1999;Cronin & Taylor, 2002).Most of the researchers found that customer satisfaction is the predictor of customer loyalty (Faullantet al., 2008;Leverin and Liljander, 2006;Terblanche, 2006). The above literature can come up with the following hypothesis:

H2: There is a significant relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty.

7. d) Trust

In business, trust is one of the most relevant determinants of stable and collaborative relationships. According to Moorman et al. (1992), trust is a willingness to rely on an exchange partner in whom one has full confidence. If one party trusts another party that eventually stimulates positive behavioral intentions towards the second party (Lau and Lee, 1999). Morgan and Hunt (1994) showed that trust is a major factor that influences relationship commitment which in turns leads to brand loyalty. According to Chauduri and Holbrook (2001), brand trust is directly related to both purchase and attitudinal loyalty. Brand trust helps the organization to sustain even during the time of uncertainty (Moorman et al., 1992 H3: There is a significant relationship between trust and customer loyalty.

8. e) Corporate Image

Image refers to the ability to influence customers' perception of the goods and services offered by the service provider (Zeithaml and Bitner, 2008). According to Nguyen and Leblanc (1998; corporate image is correlated to the physical and behavioral attributes of the organization, such as business name, variety of products or services, and the impression of quality communicated by each person communicating with the firm's clients. Thus, image will have an impact on customers' buying behavior. According to Aydin and Zer (2005) corporate image is one of the major determinants of customer loyalty and loyal customers may buy more and spread positive word-of-mouth regarding service provider. Corporate and brand image have also emerged as determinants of customer loyalty (Gronroos, 1988, Groholdt et al., 2000). The above literature can come up with the following hypothesis: H4: There is a significant relationship between corporate image and customer loyalty.

9. f) Switching Cost

Switching cost is the form of cost involved in changing from one service provider to another (Porter, 1998). According to Jackson (1985), switching cost is the sum of economic, psychological and physical costs. Switching cost are characterized by customer lock-in, where customer purchase the same brand repeatedly even competing brands have cheaper price (Aydin and Ozer,2005;Shy,2002). Previous studies showed that the degree of switching cost may have an influence on customer loyalty in service industry (Anderson and Fornell, 1994;Dick and Basu, 1994;Gremler and Brown, 1996). Jones et al., (2000) showed that switching cost is the significant antecedents for both business to business and business to consumer cases. Hence, the above literature can come up with the following hypothesis: H5: There is a significant relationship between switching cost and customer loyalty.

10. g) Development of Conceptual Framework

Service quality, Customer satisfaction, Trust, Corporate image, Switching Cost and Customer loyalty are probably the most widely used variables in the domain of relationship marketing. A research model has been proposed based on literature review to analyze the relationships among these variables in order to detect the discerning impact of several determinants on customer loyalty.

11. Methodology

This study is descriptive in nature. The main purpose of the descriptive research is validation of the developed hypothesis that reflects the existing condition (Zikmund et.al., 2012).

12. a) Sampling Design

The population of this study includes all the individuals in Bangladesh who have a connected mobile phone and used a particular operator network service more than six (6)

13. b) Data Collection Procedure and Instruments

To attain the objectives of this study both the primary and secondary data have been used. Secondary data has been collected from journals, newspapers, magazine, books, reports, and websites etc. The researcher conducts a survey to collect the primary data from the respondents who are using mobile phone services of a particular company. Primary data is collected from the respondents through survey method. Considering the nature of the study, data were collected through a structured questionnaire using 5point Likert scale where Strongly Disagree=1, Disagree=2, Neutral=3, Agree=4, and Strongly agree=5) to collect information about the determinants of customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh.

The questionnaire was designed in two parts. In part-I, to identify respondents' specific demographic criteria including name of the mobile operators, gender, age, monthly mobile expenses, occupation and education and in part-II-it includes 18 influential variables of customer loyalty in telecom industry.

14. c) Data Analysis

The data were analyzed using the Statistical Package of the Social Science (SPSS, 16.0). In this study, both the descriptive and inferential analysis techniques including reliability statistics (Cronbach Alpha), and multiple regression analysis were used to achieve this purpose.

IV.

15. Analysis and Discussion

16. a) Reliability of Data

The reliability of a measure indicates the degree to which measures are free from random error and therefore yield consistent results (Zikmund, et al., 2012). According to Nunnaly (1978),0.7 is acceptable reliability coefficient. Table-2 shows the demographics profile of the customers who use mobile phone services more than 6 months including name of the mobile operator, gender, age, monthly mobile expenses, education and occupation. From this study, it has been found that most of customers use Grameenphone (44%) while only 5% using Teletalk. It is also shown that male respondents are dominant (57%) compared to female respondents (43%).In case of age group, 26 to 35(48%) are mostly the users of mobile phone services where only 7 percent uses mobile phone services whose age above 45. The respondents monthly expenses below 500 Taka are 45% followed by 37% within the range of monthly expenses 500-100 Taka. The respondents who have HSC, Graduation and Post-graduation degree are the major users of mobile phone representing 79%. Finally, statistics related to occupation shows that significant number of the respondents are students (49%) followed by business (28%) and service (23%). In this study, multiple regression analysis has been used to find out the determinants of customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh. In table 3, the model summary shows that the R value is .646, which is the correlation of five (5) independent variables with dependent variable. It also found that the coefficient of multiple determination is R 2 =.519. This means that 51.9 percent variations in the dependent variable i.e. customer loyalty of telecom sector are explained by independent variables that are service quality, trust, customer satisfaction, corporate image, switching cost and the remaining 48.1% can be attributed by other factors which are not studied. Table 4 shows that the ANOVA test result (F= 23.729, P=.000) represents the fitness of the model. Therefore it can be concluded that the combination of the independent variables significantly predicts customer loyalty of telecom sector in Bangladesh. From table 5, it has been revealed that there is a significant positive relationship between service quality and customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh with (Beta=.364) and (p=.000? .05).This means that service quality is most significant determinants contributing more than 36% customer loyalty in telecom sector. These results of the study support H1.

17. b) Multiple Regression Analysis

18. c) Hypothesis Testing

19. Testing H2

From table 5, the result shows that there is a significant positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh with (Beta=.169) and (p=.021? .05).This means that customer satisfaction influences more than 16% customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh. These results of the study accept H2.

20. Testing H3

From table 5, the result shows that there is a significant positive relationship between trust and customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh with (Beta=.203) and (p=.006? .05).This means that trust contributes more than 20% customer loyalty in telecom sector in Bangladesh. These results of the study support H3.

21. Testing H4

From table 5, it is shown that there is a significant positive relationship between corporate image and customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh with (Beta= .159) and (p=.015 ? .05).This means that corporate image influences more than 15% customer loyalty in telecom sector in Bangladesh. These results of the study accept H4.

22. Testing H5

From table 5, the result shows that there is no significant relationship between switching cost and customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh with (Beta= -.131) and (p=.087 >.05). Hence, this result of the study rejects H5.

23. Conclusion

The study examines the determinants influencing customer loyalty in the telecom industry in Bangladesh. Multiple regression analysis is conducted in this study in order to find out influential determinants that lead customer loyalty in telecom industry. Based on previous literature, five (5) influential factors of customer loyalty were identified. The results show four factors significantly influencing the customer loyalty namely service quality, customer satisfaction, trust, corporate

24. Global Journal of Management and Business Research

Volume XVII Issue I Version I Year ( ) A image. Switching cost is an insignificant determinant in developing customer loyalty in telecom industry in the context of Bangladesh. The findings of the study also indicate that service quality is the most significant determinant of customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh. Therefore, telecom operators should focus on service quality, customer satisfaction, trust, corporate image for the purpose of customer retention and building customer loyalty.

25. VI.

26. Recommendations

Building customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh is an urgent need due to the increased competition. Few guidelines are given for telecom operators based on the findings.

? Telecom operators should improve service quality as much as possible because it is the most significant determinant of customer loyalty in telecom industry in Bangladesh.

Figure 1.
2017
Year
Volume XVII Issue I Version I
( ) A
Global Journal of Management and Business Research
Figure 2.
students with any level of education but must have age
15 years.
Service Quality
Customer Satisfaction
Customer Loyalty
Trust
Corporate Image
Switching Cost
Figure 3. Table 1 :
1
Cronbach's Alpha No of Items
.815 18
From table 1, Cronbach's alpha is .815 which variables. These results of reliability ensure a proper
indicates a high level of internal consistency among 18 ground for further analysis.
Figure 4. Table 2 :
2
Variables Respondents N= 200 Frequency (%)
Name of the Mobile Operators
Grameenphone 88 44%
Banglalink 51 26%
Robi 32 16%
Airtel 18 9%
Teletalk 11 5%
Gender
Male 114 57%
Female 86 43%
Age (Years)
15-25 57 29%
26-35 96 48%
36-45 33 16%
Above 45 14 7%
Monthly Mobile Expenses
Below 500 TK 89 45%
500-1000 TK 74 37%
1000-1500 TK 31 15%
Above 1500TK 6 3%
Figure 5. Table 3 :
3
Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate
1 .646 a .519 .503 .78599
a. Predictors: (Constant), Switching Cost, Customer Satisfaction, Corporate Image, Trust,
Service Quality
Figure 6. Table 4 :
4
Model Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regression 112.622 5 22.524 23.729 .000 a
Residual 184.152 194 .949
Total 296.774 199
a. Predictors: (Constant), Switching Cost, Customer Satisfaction, Corporate Image, Trust, Service
Quality
b. Dependent Variable: Customer Loyalty
Figure 7. Table 5 :
5
Model Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig.
B Std. Error Beta
1 (Constant) .503 .771 .652 .515
Service Quality .505 .106 .364 4.765 .000
Customer Satisfaction .237 .102 .169 2.318 .021
Trust .261 .094 .203 2.773 .006
Corporate Image .214 .087 .159 2.443 .015
Switching Cost -.182 .106 -.131 -1.721 .087
a. Dependent Variable: Customer Loyalty
Testing H1
Figure 8.
1
2

Appendix A

Appendix A.1 Global Journals Inc. (US) Guidelines Handbook 2017

www.GlobalJournals.org

Appendix B

  1. , http://www.btrc.gov.bd/telco/mobile Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission. Available at Internet
  2. The chain of effects from brand trust and brand affect to brand performance: the role of brand loyalty. A Chauduri , M B Holbrook . Journal of Marketing 2001. 65 (2) p. .
  3. Does relationship marketing improve customer relationship satisfaction and loyalty?. A Leverlin , V Liljander . International Journal of Bank Marketing 2006. 24 (4) p. .
  4. SERVQUAL: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality. A Parasuraman , V A Zeithaml , L L Berry . Journal of Retailing 1988. 64 p. .
  5. A conceptual model of service quality and its implication on future research. A Parusaraman , V Zeithamal , L Berry . Journal of Marketing 1985. 48 p. .
  6. Customer loyalty: toward an integrated conceptual framework. A S Dick , K Basu . Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 1994. 22 p. .
  7. Winning and Keeping Industrial Customers, B B Jackson . 1997. Lexington Books, Lexington, MA.
  8. A national customer satisfaction barometer: The Swedish experience. C Fornell . Journal of Marketing 1992. 56 p. .
  9. A Service Quality Model and its Implications. C Gronroos . European Journal of Marketing 1984. 18 (4) p. .
  10. Service quality: The six criteria of good perceived service quality. C Gronroos . Review of Business 1988. 9 p. .
  11. Relationships between providers and users of market research: the dynamics of trust within and between organizations. C Moorman , G Zaltman , R Deshpande . Journal of Marketing Research 1992. 29 (3) p. .
  12. Service loyalty: its nature, importance, and implications. D Gremler , S W Brown . International service quality association, (New York
    ) 1996. p. .
  13. Perceived service quality: Analyzing relationships among employees, customers, and financial performance. D K Yoo , J A Park . International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management 2007. 24 (9) p. .
  14. The Antecedents and Consequences of Customer Satisfaction For Firms. E Anderson , M Sullivan . Marketing Science 1993. 12 (Spring) p. .
  15. A framework for comparing customer satisfaction across individuals and product categories. E W Anderson , C Fornell . Journal of Economic Psychology 1994. 12 p. .
  16. Developing Buyer-Seller Relationships, F R Dwyer , P H Schurr , S Oh . 1987. 51 p. .
  17. The service provider switching model (SPSM): A model of consumer switching behavior in the service industry. H Bansal , S F Taylor . Journal of Service Research 1999. 2 (2) p. .
  18. Moving Forward in Service Quality: Measuring Different Customer-Expectations Levels, Comparing Alternative Scales, and Examining the Performance-Behavioral Intentions Link. J C Nunally , A Parasuraman , V A Zeithaml , L L Berry . http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/57/27/44088872.pdf40 Psychometric Theory, (New York; Cambridge, MA
    ) 1978. 2008. 1994. McGraw Hill. OECD. (The economic impact of counterfeiting and piracy)
  19. Cusomer satisfaction and loyalty in a digital environment: an empirical test. J Donio , P Massari , G Passiante . The Journal of Consumer Marketing 2006. 23 (7) p. .
  20. Measuring service quality: A re-examination and extension. J J Cronin , S A Taylor . Journal of Marketing 1992. 56 (3) p. .
  21. Putting the Service-Profit Chain to Work. J L Heskett , T O Jones , G W Loveman , W E Sasser , L A Schlesinger . Harvard Business Review 1994. March -April. p. .
  22. Putting The Service-Profit Chain To Work. J L Heskett , T O Jones , G W Loveman , W E Sasser , L A Schlesinger . Harvard Business Review 1994. March -April. p. .
  23. K A Venetis , P Ghauri . Service quality and customer retention: Building long term, 2004.
  24. Consumer trust in a brand and link to brand loyalty. Lau , S Lee . Journal of Market Focused Management 1999. 4 p. .
  25. What we need to know to develop strategies and tactics to improve service delivery. L Fogli . Customer Service Delivery: Research and best practices, L Fogli (ed.) (San Francisco
    ) 2006. Jossey-Bass. p. .
  26. The relationship between customer satisfaction and loyalty: cross-industry differences. L Grönholdt , A Martensen , K Kristensen . Total Quality Management 2000. 11 (4/5/6) p. .
  27. The service quality puzzle. L L Berry , A Parasuraman , V A Zeithamal . Business Horizon 1988. 31 (5) p. .
  28. Study of the relationship between customer satisfaction and loyalty in telecom enterprise. L Liu . 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing, 2008. p. .
  29. Switching barriers and repurchase intentions in services. M A Jones , D L Mothersbaugh , S E Beatty . Journal of Retailing 2000. 76 (2) p. .
  30. Mobile Subscribers. BTRC 2017. (cited 14)
  31. M Porter . Competitive Strategy: Techniques for analyzing Industries and Competitors, (New York, NY
    ) 1996. The free Press.
  32. The mediating role of corporate image on consumers retention decisions: an investigation in financial services. N & Nguyen , G Leblanc . International journal of Bank Marketing 1998. 16 (2) p. .
  33. Corporate image and corporate reputation in customers' retention decisions in services. N Nguyen , G Leblanc . Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 2001. 8 p. .
  34. The relationship between customer satisfaction and loyalty: an application of American customer satisfaction index in the South African fast food industry. N S Terblanche . Management Dynamics 2006. 15 (2) p. .
  35. A Quick and Easy Method for Estimating Switching Costs. O Shy . International Journal of Industrial Organization 2002. 20 p. .
  36. Principles of Marketing, P Kotler , G Armstrong . 2012. Pearson Prentice Hall. (14th Global Edition)
  37. An Examination of the Nature of Trustin Buyer-Seller Relationships. P M Doney , J P Cannon . Journal of Marketing 1997. 61 p. .
  38. The PIMS principles: linking strategy to performance, R D Buzzell , B T Gale . 1987. New York: The Free Press.
  39. The imapact of satisfaction and image on loyalty: the case of alpine ski resorts. R Faullant , K Matzler , J Fuller . Manging Service Quality 2008. 18 (2) p. .
  40. Satisfaction: A Behavioral pers pective on the consumer. R L Oliver . European Journal of Marketing 1997. McGraw Hill. relationships. 38 (11/12) p. .
  41. The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing. R M Morgan , S D Hunt . Journal of Marketing 1994. 58 p. .
  42. A multistage model of customers' assessments of service quality and value. R N Bolton , J H Drew . Journal of Consumer Research 1991. 17 p. .
  43. The analysis of antecedents of customer loyalty in the Turkish mobile telecommunication market. S Aydin , O G Zer . European Journal of Marketing 2005. 39 (7/8) p. .
  44. The analysis of antecedents of customer loyalty in the Turkish mobile telecommunication market. S Aydin , G Ozer . European Journal of Marketing 2005. 39 (7) p. .
  45. An empirical analysis of customer loyalty in Pakistan's telecommunication industry. S Jahanzeb , F Tasneem , B Khan . Database Marketing & Customer Strategy Management, 2011. 18 p. .
  46. Exploring influencing factors for the selection of mobile phone service providers: A structural equational modelling (SEM) approach on Malaysian consumers. S Rahman , A Haque , S A Ismail . African Journal of Business Management 2010. 4 (13) p. .
  47. Segmenting customer brand relations: Beyond the personal relationship metaphor. Story , J Hess . Journal of Consumer Marketing 2006. 23 (7) p. .
  48. The driving forces of customer loyalty: a study of internet service providers in Hong Kong. T Cheng , L Lai , A Yeung . International Journal of E-business Research 2008. 4 (4) p. .
  49. Improving the measurement of service quality. T J Brown , G A Churchill , J P Peter . J. Retail 1992. 69 p. .
  50. The behavioral consequences of service quality. V A Zeithaml , L L Berry , A Parasuraman . Journal of Marketing 1996. 60 p. .
  51. V A Zeithaml , A Wilson , M J Bitner . Services marketing, (New Delhi
    ) 2008. The McGraw-Hill Companies. (4th edition)
  52. Business Research Method: South Asian Perspective, W G Zikmund , B J Babin , J C Carr , A Adhikari , M Griffin . 2007. Cengage Learing India Pvt.Ltd (th ed.)
Notes
1
© 2017 Global Journals Inc. (US)
2
© 2017 Global Journals Inc. (US) 1
Date: 2017-01-15